
Most readers of this of this blog probably haven't read too
much Patricia Cornwell, but her earlier Kay Scarpetta novels are
wonderful. What separates them from the
herd is the rare combination of good writing and meaningful plot. While it may be "all about the characters,"
characters, by themselves, do not a novel make.
Likewise, all the plot in the world doesn't help much if the characters
are nothing more than cardboard cutouts, the literary answer to "Buddy Jesus." In case you're not sure what I mean, I refer
to you to Terry Goodkind's entire body of work.
Unfortunately, even good writers tend to go bad after awhile; Patricia
Cornwell's most recent books are complete drivel. Now, many people have this--these days
somewhat sacrilegious--complaint about the last few novels in the Wheel of Time
Series, but trust me, in comparison to Predator, they're all action packed.
Which brings me to Simon R. Green. He's an ambitious writer; his offerings span
the gamut, from crime novels to satires to Laurell K. Hamilton rip-offs. I know, because I've read most of his books,
even though, well, to be honest, they aren't very good. He's like that good for nothing boyfriend
most of us remember from college: he's incapable of having a real conversation,
you'd die of embarrassment if your family ever met him, but somehow you can't
quite bring yourself to break up with him.
Green's books fill a similar void: I go back to them when I'm between
series, because they're dependable. I
sort of care about the characters, I'm mildly interested in what happens to
them, and I have no guilt about abandoning them if something better comes
along. Until recently, I'd meandered
through about half his catalogue, and I was pretty confident I knew what he was
about. So, imagine my surprise when I
picked up the first book in the Deathstalker series, read a few chapters...and
discovered that it was actually good!
This afternoon, I finished the last few pages of the fourth
installment of the series,
Deathstalker Honor.
Last week, when I realized I only had a few hundred pages to go, I began
scouring all of my local bookstores in a vain search to locate the fifth
installment; as it turns out, bookstores only stock installments one through
three.
I'm guessing this means that most
people lose interest in the series pretty quickly.
Ultimately, I broke down and ordered the rest
of the series--four more books--on
Amazon.com and, since then, I've been savoring
those pages like fine wine.
What makes the series good is its plot. It has, without qualification, the best plot
of any new series I've read. Green
provides an exciting blend of humanity and technology, lots of well-paced
action, original--and believable--plot twists, and intrigue. There's a satisfying amount of variety, as
well; he switches deftly from conflict to conflict. I really got into the trials and tribulations
of his universe. Especially since some
of my old standards have deserted me lately, it excited me to discover another
really absorbing series.
His characters, unfortunately, are more plot vehicles than
anything else. They're more in the Terry
Goodkind school than the George R.R. Martin; Goodkind's characters all chew the
scenery while worrying about how to save the world, and Martin's all act out of
self loathing. Here, Green's heroes are
all survivors of a mysterious "madness maze," which endows all who survive it
with ever expanding magical powers--that, fortunately, change to suit the
circumstances. Actually, I think it's a
testament to Green's writing ability that the series is still interesting. He manages to exploit his heroes' powers
while maintaining the integrity of the conflicts they face. Never once does he use them as an "easy fix." In fact, when they're not in the throes of
existential angst over the changing nature of their humanity--which is a little
Our Bodies, Ourselves--they're surprisingly believable. My issue is that Green concentrates on what
his characters experience almost to the exclusion of his characters themselves. He never fully reveals their inner lives,
only gives us brief glimpses.
Resultantly, their moments of doubt, internal conflicts, and even their
love affairs are static.
The most serious issue I have with Green's writing is, well,
the writing itself. Often, it's so
florid that it obscures what it's trying to illuminate. He reminds me of a precocious teenager,
anxious to test out his new vocabulary.
Moreover, adding insult to injury, Green tends to reuse phrases. I think every single character has a "death's
head grin" on every single page. If it
were a drinking game, then I'd be dead by page ten. If he could learn to get away from catch
phrases, cute phrases and "meaningful" comparisons--rosaries hanging off of hips
like guns, rain falling like tears, and worse--I think he'd be a good writer.
The thing is, he's not.
This series is good, and I really do recommend it--but it's Green's
obviously incredible imagination that separates him from the average eleventh
grader with delusions of grandeur.
Ultimately, the only litmus test that matters, when it comes to defining
"good" is, do you want to continue to read this book? Do you care if you ever see it again? Far too often, so called "good" writers leave
us with series that we're convinced we should like--"hard reads" that leave us feeling
vaguely inferior. Here, the fact that
I'm a better writer than Green only increases my enjoyment of his work. I give the series a solid B.
Leave a comment